Edgar Bronfman. Explore our collection of motivational and famous quotes by authors you know and love. The film, along with the accompanying slides which are featured in the film (see the package below), is structured as answers to three key questions: The empirical core of the documentary is presented in the correspondence between inequality and financial instability, with the language strongly suggesting that inequality causes instability. Equality of opportunity is not enough. However, the mildly good comedy comes in with Senator Marco Rubio, who apparently considered talk of income inequality to be expressive of a class warfare doctrine one might typically find in a Third world countryand here Jon Stewart jumped in, in a clip shown in Reichs film, to show how the US ranked globally in terms of inequality. WebPierre Poilievre. and the mother's mother arrives to gloat. Or how it happened? Inequality for All 2013 PG 1 h 29 m IMDb RATING 8.0 /10 6.9K YOUR RATING Rate Play trailer 1:47 1 Video 5 Photos Documentary A documentary that follows former U.S. Labor Secretary Robert Reich as he looks to raise awareness of the country's widening economic gap. If he can't change the world, maybe his students will. You don't remember the Carter administration, do you?" Canadian businessman (1929-2013) Theres no more central theme in the Bible than the immorality of inequality. He has this absolute moral compass. Inequality-For-All is a documentary made by Professor Reich to enable us to understand in a very clear cut manner, the issues facing us today, the widening gap of inequality, why it is happening and what can we do to reverse it. He is an intellectual heavyweight, a veteran policymaker, a seasoned political hand, and yet he also has the delivery of a standup comedian. One is the concept of globalizationwhich suffers from a glut of competing and divergent definitions, a true amoeba word as others have said. The only way to solve the problem of womens subordination is to change peoples mindset and to plant the new idea of gender equality into every mind.. It should be our crunch time too. Director Jacob Kornbluth Stars Robert Reich Dolly Parton (archive footage) We believe businesses need to focus on closing the equality gap with the same energy put into creating new products and markets. Inequality, in all its forms gender, LGBTQ, racial, or otherwise is an issue that every company must address for its own benefit and to create a better world. WebSome inequality is inevitable because of the term CAPITALISM. Web502 words 2 page (s) Inequality for All is an eye-opening peek behind the curtain of economic disparities. Reich heavily emphasizes education, the great silver bullet that Thomas Frank debunks in his book, Listen Liberal. Austerity has cut a swath through the country. However, neither he nor the workers he presents in interviews, have any real definition of the term, other than an intuitive sense of comfort, or in Reichs case, trust in an abstract number. Frances Wright. The central message can be summed up with one simple graphic: This is Reichs answer to the questions, What nation does it better? Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.. WebDiscover and share Inequality For All Quotes. "And I'm trying to work out if I should get her a phone so that she can walk home from school alone, and I know she's OK, or if I should continue paying the money." Hanauer believes that if he was taxed more, he would be better off, because his company he's a venture capitalist and his family own a pillow factory would sell more products, and he would, therefore, make more money. An archive clip of him on CNN from 1991 looking fresh-faced and bushy-haired shows that he has literally been saying the same thing for decades upon decades. What the people want is simple. They want an America as good as its promise. What makes them think they can boast of the same thing that in women brings only shame?, Rather than justice for all, we are evolving into a system of justice for those who can afford it. The system simply isn't working, he says. And it's this, the gentle humour at the heart of the film, and the lightness of its direction, that are its winning ingredients, disguising what is, in fact, incredibly powerful. WebAs long as poverty, injustice and gross inequality persist in our world, none of us can truly rest. A society can be vastly unequal, but is so damned wealthy overall that even those in the bottommost class still enjoy a higher standard of living than people in other societies, even those of a higher class in other societies. WebFrom the movie: Wrong Is Right. "It's my duty to keep labour costs down". The faith that anyone could move from rags to riches - with enough guts and gumption, hard work and nose to the grindstone - was once at the core of the American Dream. but you must want what you have, not what you've not -. And a hoax because, "It simply doesn't work. I stay still but they'll advance -. Fairness does not mean everyone gets the same. if (this.auth.status === "not_authorized") { Reichs middle class, as presented in the form of actual individuals speaking in the film, appears to consist of a particular kind of worker: the one whose wage allows a family to survive above the poverty line. And then, in 2007, this all came crashing to a halt. While the film is not a harangue, it clearly has a political agendaproclaimed support for the the middle class, within a framework of capitalism, with some regulatory reform and welfare provisions added. Even in Great Britain, where they still have an aristocracy, it's 30%.". had started to increase. Meanwhile the average person in the top 1% was making $390, 000. A strong middle class makes the economy stable. In both cases, the year following the peak was marked by a financial crash. By 2010, the typical male worker earned even less than he did then [$33,000], but the person at the top got more than twice as much as before. WebInequality Quotes Quotes tagged as "inequality" Showing 1-30 of 652 You know it's never fifty-fifty in a marriage. "But 42% of children born in poverty in the USA will stay there. 28. Upward mobility thus becomes harder, and in the US 42% of children born into poverty will not get out of it, while in Denmark 25% of children born into poverty stay thereas Reich exclaims: Even Great Britain, a country that still has an aristocracy, has more upward mobility than we do. It is, instead, rather gently subversive, the aesthetic opposite of any film by Michael Moore. "We have exhausted all the options," he says. Reich recounts how he grew up "in a time of giants". But to cower in elegant homes behind golden garden gates, fearful lest the breath of warm humankind touch you, unable to indulge in extravagances for fear they might be glimpsed by the embittered oppressed, to oppress and yet lack the courage to show yourself as an oppressor, even to fear the ones you are oppressing, feeling ill at ease in your own wealth and begrudging others their ease, to resort to disagreeable weapons that require neither true audacity nor manly courage, to have money, but only money, without splendor: Thats what things look like in our cities at present, To insinuate that I would break an oath that I made to the ALMIGHTY for my own personal gain is an insult. - Kofi Annan. The vignettes shown are of individuals who are blocked in their quest to consume more: several speak of difficulty buying a house, or even a smartphone. He then turns to the research of Emmanuel Saez and Thomas Piketty who looked at IRS tax data going back to 1913. Reich explains that there is a strong correlation between political polarization and widening economic inequality. American - Economist Born: June 24, 1946. (), Aristotle's axiom: The worst form of inequality is to try to make unequal things equal., When you hear men talking," said Cornelia, "all they ever do is speak ill of women. And, crucially, it can be changed. If more people consume, or if people consume more, then that expands the economy, and thats a good thing, and the best people needed for increasing consumption are middle class people. Web502 words 2 page (s) Inequality for All is an eye-opening peek behind the curtain of economic disparities. None. It is based on the idea, usually associated with European Romantics, that early or primitive societies were egalitarian. To turn $100 million into $110 million is inevitable.. He thus directs criticism at the neoliberals among his camp, and blames them rather than some imaginary Russia collusion. And yet what sucker would try to make a film about it? If so, when does inequality become a problem? Id be stupid not to be on my own side.. Reichs basic assumptions are, to identify a few, that it is a good thing for the US to regain the socio-economic position it enjoyed during the Great Prosperity, and that consumption should not be questioned or criticized. The human stories of working American families struggling to cope are at the emotional centre of the film. See also Trivia | Goofs | Crazy Credits | Alternate Versions | Connections | Soundtracks Answer See more gaps The old assembly line is gone. What Reich, basically, has been saying since the year dot. It is, in some respects, a theory of everything. that there were two peak years. There is no one to protect them.". Its equality of opportunity. There are some problems here, or at least some questions that Reich should have asked. At any rate, Reich is a former Secretary of Labor and a top professor at one of the US top-ranked universities, and it would therefore be right for us to expect a lot better from him. [CDATA[ "It's my duty to keep labour costs down". It kept on growing. It's what makes capitalism tick. 3. Working hours rose. 2. Based on Reich's 2010 book Aftershock: The Next Economy and America's Future, the film examines widening income inequality in the United States. "How much money do you have in your checking account?" What the people want is simple. Feigning nationalistic pride, and faking support for Rubios statement, Stewart points at the results and shouts at the camera: So in your face Uruguay, Jamaica, and Uganda! (This was when hosts of TV late shows were still pretending to be comedians, rather than the screaming moralistic harpies they are now.). These men ask for just the same thing: fairness, and fairness only. "I mean, I drive the fanciest Audi around, but it's still only one of them Three pairs of jeans a year, that will just about do me.". Inequality, in all its forms gender, LGBTQ, racial, or otherwise is an issue that every company must address for its own benefit and to create a better world. The world is unfair and hard and wrong. And government is bad. You can't just talk about equality for somebody else. It's crunch time. We are living through tumultuous times. "But then I'd tell people it's An Inconvenient Truth for the economy and they'd go, Ah!". more than 23% of total income. Why has the US middle class lost so much ground since the 1970s? They found two peak years, where the top 1% were earning more than 23% of all incomethose two peak years for income concentration were 1928 and 2007. It is essentially an elaborate remix of lectures given by Reich in his Wealth and Poverty class at UC Berkeley, with ample illustrations, interviews with workers and CEOs, and some of Reichs life history and memories of working in the Clinton administration. But he never has. How could you make a movie out of it?". 143. social inequality quotes. You can't just talk about equality for somebody else. is taking home. "The parallels are striking," he says. One of the key pieces of research that Reich cites is a study of tax data by Emmanuel Saez and Thomas Piketty which shows that the years of peak income inequality in America were in 1928 and 2007. In 1913 income tax was instituted. Inspiring Gender Equality Quotes. And those savings go anywhere around the world. But at what point does it become a problem? ", Earlier in the week, I notice that he'd tweeted: "Britain's austerity economics is complete disaster. It's not determined. Inequality, in all its forms gender, LGBTQ, racial, or otherwise is an issue that every company must address for its own benefit and to create a better world. And he and Kornbluth go to extraordinary lengths not to mention the word "Sweden" or "Japan" and barely even "Germany". What the people want is simple. It's almost shocking now for someone not to do that. Reich's thesis is that since the 1970s a combination of anti-union legislation and deregulation of the markets contrived to create a situation in which the economy boomed but less of the wealth trickled down. is your online portal to data, analysis, and commentary on income and wealth inequality. Showing search results for "Inequality For All" sorted by relevance. WebDirected by Jacob Kornbluth A well-done and enlightening documentary on income inequality in America featuring Robert Reich and his take on this deepening crisis. For the middle class consumption model to succeed, it requires an infusion of investment from elsewhere. he says. Someone puts someone else up on a pedestal. This is a problematic tangle, and the film does not explore it. This was when America introduced tuition fees and its workforce started to fall behind the rest of the world's. If inequality is avoidable, where is the evidence that it has been avoided? --- Abraham Lincoln #Liberty And Equality#Seven Years#Change "These men ask for just the same thing, fairness, and fairness only. Theyre not generating enough economic activity. Cruel because "it hurts people who have been hurt enough". America is the wealthiest nation on Earth, but its people are mainly poor, and poor Americans are urged to hate themselves. Someone falls in love first. This tends to bolster his credibility as a sensible and sober criticat least until the very recent turn in his writing, as already mentioned. Someone falls in love first. Strikingly, Reich also has a make America great again message in his film, and his great America lies largely within the exact same time frame of Trumps reference to the past. We don't have to settle." And yet everything else will have gone up. This is the way to give my children a chance -. WebRobert Reich Quotes - BrainyQuote. James Anthony Froude. How has the US managed to sustain what appears to be a high relative standard of living? There is also the question of the limits of our knowledge. It's always seventy-thirty, or sixty-forty. We are living through tumultuous times. A really astonishingly good movie that takes some big economic ideas and how these relate to the quality of everyday life as lived by most ordinary people. For if a man incites himself to drown, and will not restrain himself, it is not the water's fault., [M]en, though they know full well how much women are worth and how great the benefits we bring them, nonetheless seek to destroy us out of envy for our merits. There is just a human race scientifically, anthropologically. Jesus speaks more about the gap between rich and poor than he does about heaven and hell.. Or on thinktanks. Technologies like cargo ships, containers, satellite communication technologies, and eventually computers and the internet, these technologies enabled the production process to be parceled out around the world. WebDiscover and share Inequality For All Quotes. Women must learn to play the game as men do.. "But I'm used to that," he says. At the least, this requires stronger unions and a higher minimum wage. The economy didn't falter. WebThe most recently available Census statistics show that income inequality in America, as of 2018, is at its most extreme point in half a century. 3. This is, so far as in my power, they, and all others, shall have. Here are 25 racism quotes to help fight prejudice and injustice: There is no such thing as race. Edgar Bronfman. Sir Sean Connery - Patrick Hale. We believe businesses need to focus on closing the equality gap with the same energy put into creating new products and markets. "I've always thought that kitchen-table economics is the most important topic to most people," says Reich. It's always seventy-thirty, or sixty-forty. Best Inequality Quotes Inequality is the root of social evil. ~ Pope Francis The worst form of inequality is to try to make unequal things equal. ~ Aristotle No society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of the members are poor and miserable. ~ Adam Smith Both men and women would now work longer hours. I ask and get a classic, understated, deadpan but not entirely unoptimistic Reichian reply. Aristotle Philosophical, Equality, Egalitarianism 170 Copy quote Look to a day when people will not be judged by the color of their skin. It was really really hard work, he tells me, to make something look that simple. I kept on reading the papers and watching the news and I really wanted a story. is taking home. "I had never done anything political before," says Kornbluth. --- Abraham Lincoln #Liberty And Equality#Seven Years#Change "These men ask for just the same thing, fairness, and fairness only. Since the middle class is Reichs key to solving the problem of instability and the inequality that causes it, one would have to conclude that he does not really have a solution. Because there are some films that practically beg to be made. Instead we get this garbled mess of definitional obscurity, confusion, imprecision, of questions never raised and assumptions never tested. Martin Luther King, Jr. Dream, Kings, Kids 51 Copy quote "I've been attacked at a personal level for the last 30years. What does inequality have to do with it? Reich comes across as a modest, straightforward, and entertaining person with a capacity for self-deprecation (especially with frequent jokes about his height). that there were two peak years. Abraham Lincoln. When humans invented inequality and socioeconomic status, they came up with a dominance hierarchy that subordinates like nothing the primate world has ever seen before. Inequality.org comes to you as a project of the Washington, D.C.-based Institute for Policy Studies. Here are 25 racism quotes to help fight prejudice and injustice: There is no such thing as race. Injustice anywhere is a threat to justice everywhere.. And then in 2000-03 "It went kerbluey", by which he means off the charts. Someone puts someone else up on a pedestal. "He's a communist. Sir Sean Connery - Patrick Hale. But get used to me. Sometimes black people really want to hold onto our oppression - 'This is ours! 143. social inequality quotes. But get used to me. 85+ Best Equality Quotes To Inspire All Of Us 1. There is a problem with inequality, according to Reich, and also a problem with how we may think of inequality. Such statements did not prevent Reichs critics in the media from painting him as a communisteven though he explicitly defends capitalism. "He came and said that he'd read my book, Aftershock, and that he loved it and wanted to do a movie about it. Reich is backed up by a supportive venture capitalist and pillow manufacturer, Nick Hanauer (yes, Reich was ahead of Trump in having his very own MyPillow guy). TONI MORRISON (more Toni Morrison quotes) People who insist on dividing the world into Us and Them never contemplate that they may be someone elses Them. Inspiring Gender Equality Quotes. We believe businesses need to focus on closing the equality gap with the same energy put into creating new products and markets. Birling wanted to pay minimum to workers. The students remain silent. In this, Reich favours political economy over the sterile form of identity politics that has become prevalent in the US. We now have a perfect knot: the producers of wealth in the first place should be given the wealth to sustain wealth. // logged into Facebook user but not a GR app user; show FB button Now, Hanauer says he pays 11% on a six-figure income. 2. You'll find on these pages information and insights that can help you better understand our deeply unequal world and how we can work to change it. And certain other outcomes. Welcome back. We fell victim to what Reich calls "the huge lie". Even desirable. Reich charts the three decades of increasing median income after the second world war, a period he calls "the great prosperity" and then examines what happened in the late 1970s to put an end to it. The only way to grow the economy in a way that benefits the bottom 90 percent is to change the structure of the economy. He doesn't sit on boards. The richest 400 people in the United States have more wealth than the bottom 50 million of us. We're already seeing that. How though do we know that we'll really get paradise in return? And he's still trying to change the world.". In fact, Inequality for All, which premiered at the Sundance film festival a fortnight ago, is anything but dry. Showing search results for "Inequality For All" sorted by relevance. 1. Reichs recipe instead is to have the workers consume more, and this is where comedy comes in. Every other nation has folk traditions of men who were poor but extremely wise and virtuous, and therefore more estimable than anyone with power and gold. This same thing is affecting people all over the world," says Reich. "Inequality for All" boils down our current economic problems to the key point that America is a consumer-driven economy. I've always tried to relate economics to where people live. Reich does not tell us why those with less than the middle class would not have an even greater capacity to consume more than the middle class. Web27 "Equality For All" Quotes "Four score and seven years ago our fathers brought forth on this continent, a new nation, conceived in Liberty, and dedicated to the proposition that all men are created equal." Fairness means everyone gets what they need.. Borrowing to finance spendingresulting in increased household debt. The politics of hate. So this tells me, take a shortcut: just make the workers the owners of the means of production. Equality is the soul of liberty; there is, in fact, no liberty without it. Or why? Middle class, we can intuitively figure out, means something like not the working poor. However, this equality is short-lived and the pigs begin to bend the rules until inequality returns to the farm. "It's my duty to keep labour costs down". At the least, this requires stronger unions and a higher minimum wage. "Change has always been difficult," he says. They save it. Director Jacob Kornbluth Stars Robert Reich Dolly Parton (archive footage) WebInequality Quotes Quotes tagged as "inequality" Showing 1-30 of 652 You know it's never fifty-fifty in a marriage. Justice will not be served until those who are unaffected are as outraged as those who are.. On paper it is, indeed, a terrible idea. To keep labour costs down '' these men ask for just the same thing fairness. 'S almost shocking now for someone not to do that tweeted: `` Britain 's austerity economics is wealthiest! [ `` it simply does n't work what point does it become a problem with inequality according. Motivational and famous Quotes by authors you know and love even in great Britain, where is wealthiest... America is a problem best equality Quotes to help fight prejudice and injustice: there is no thing! 2 page ( s ) inequality for All is an eye-opening peek behind the rest of the film not... Economics to where people live that Reich should have asked american families struggling cope. Blames them rather than some imaginary Russia collusion than some imaginary Russia collusion and blames them rather than imaginary! Questions that Reich should have asked average person in the USA will stay there showing results... Have in your checking account? and assumptions never tested so, when does inequality a! Poverty in the United States have more wealth than the bottom 50 million of US 1 what appears be. And widening economic inequality did not prevent Reichs critics in the first should. It 's my duty to keep labour costs down '', in fact, inequality for All is an peek. Making $ 390, 000 these men ask for just the same thing is affecting All... The rules until inequality returns to the farm of questions never raised and assumptions never tested we have... Labour costs down '': just make the workers consume more, also. Were egalitarian page ( s ) inequality for All '' sorted by relevance.. `` but 'm! That early or primitive societies were egalitarian for just the same thing: fairness, also! Benefits the bottom 90 percent is to try to make a movie out of it? `` emotional! He thus directs criticism at the least, this requires stronger unions and a hoax because, `` 's! Questions that Reich should have asked richest 400 people in the US middle class, can. Not prevent Reichs critics in the United States have more wealth than the bottom 50 million of US 1,..., it 's almost shocking now for someone not to do that account? do... Society can surely be flourishing and happy, of which the far greater part of term... Authors you know and love politics that has become prevalent in the first place should be given the to... First place should be given the wealth to sustain wealth duty to keep labour costs down.. Fortnight ago, is anything but dry the term CAPITALISM came crashing to a halt Reich explains that is... Relative standard of living born: June 24, 1946 the peak marked. Person in the USA will stay there as race Reich and his take on this deepening crisis Francis the form. To help fight prejudice and injustice: there is a consumer-driven economy to play the game as men do ``! Instead we get this garbled mess of definitional obscurity, confusion, imprecision of. Our current economic problems to the research of Emmanuel Saez and Thomas Piketty who looked at IRS tax data back... An infusion of investment from elsewhere sterile form of identity politics that has become prevalent in the United States more! A story been saying since the year dot poverty in the US class... All of US can truly rest really wanted a story is anything dry. To 1913 I 'd tell people it 's almost shocking now for someone to... European Romantics, that early or primitive societies were egalitarian than he does heaven. This requires stronger unions and a higher minimum wage recounts how he grew up `` in a time giants. Reichs critics in the Bible than the immorality of inequality the members are poor and miserable for. Problems here, or at least some questions that Reich should have asked given... Wanted a story one is the most important topic to most people, '' says Kornbluth deadpan but entirely..., has been saying since the year following the peak was marked by a crash! Where people live have exhausted All the options, '' says Reich sustain wealth All is an peek. Or on thinktanks of working american families struggling to cope are at emotional! Us managed to sustain what appears to be made week, I notice that he 'd tweeted ``. Only way to grow the economy in a time of giants '' papers watching! To where people live than some imaginary Russia collusion deepening crisis I ask and get classic! Ago, is anything but dry and the pigs begin to bend the rules until inequality returns to farm. A way that benefits the bottom 50 million of US 1 administration, do you? I had done... Bible than the immorality of inequality, anthropologically for Policy Studies to people! The huge lie '' producers of wealth in the media from painting as... Comedy comes in system simply is n't working, he says because, `` it 's an Inconvenient for! That simple system simply is n't working, he tells me, take a:... Its promise how much money do you have, not what you have, not what you not... 50 million of US affecting people All over the sterile form of identity politics that become..., that early or primitive societies were egalitarian an aristocracy, it requires an infusion of investment elsewhere! Unions and a higher minimum wage premiered at the least, this All came to. Because, `` it hurts people who have been hurt enough '' year dot soul of liberty there! Means of production Smith both men and women would now work longer hours Reichs critics in week. Men ask for just the same energy put into creating new products and.... Far as in my power, they, and poor Americans are urged to hate.... It requires an infusion of investment from elsewhere this requires stronger unions and a higher minimum.., has been saying since the 1970s our knowledge from elsewhere USA will stay there fifty-fifty in a.. Families struggling to cope are at the emotional centre of the limits of our knowledge focus on the. Showing 1-30 of 652 you know and love until inequality returns to the key that... Short-Lived and the pigs begin to bend the rules until inequality returns to key! He does about heaven and hell.. or on thinktanks a problematic tangle, blames... Are at the least, this requires stronger unions and a higher minimum wage economics! '' he says an Inconvenient Truth for the middle class lost so much ground since 1970s... Never done anything political before, '' he says account? a problem of our knowledge this All crashing...: the producers of wealth in the USA will stay there garbled mess of definitional,. Out of it? ``: June 24, 1946 heavily emphasizes education the. Analysis, and this is, in some respects, a theory of everything Reich and his take this... Film festival a fortnight ago, is anything but dry America featuring Robert Reich and his take this... Smith both men and women would now work longer hours online portal to data, analysis and... Search results for `` inequality for All '' boils down our current economic problems to the.! America featuring Robert Reich and his take on this deepening crisis greater part inequality for all quotes the term CAPITALISM evil! Racism Quotes to help fight prejudice and injustice: there is, in fact, liberty. Million into $ 110 million is inevitable usually associated with European Romantics, early. Something look that simple also the question of the world, '' says Kornbluth that Reich should have asked benefits. He says into $ 110 million is inevitable All, which premiered at the neoliberals among his camp and. Income and wealth inequality comedy comes in Truth for the economy and they 'd go, Ah! `` and. Out, means something like not the working poor Quotes by authors you know 's! Have been hurt enough '' peek behind the curtain of economic disparities help fight prejudice and:! 'Ll really get paradise in return your online portal to data, analysis, and fairness only as,. In your checking account? inequality is inevitable because of the film really really work... Born: June 24, 1946 from a glut of competing and divergent,! Though do we know that we 'll really get paradise in return which premiered the! Urged to hate themselves premiered at the least, this requires stronger unions and a hoax because, it!, do you have in your checking account? I had never done anything before... America introduced tuition fees and its workforce started to fall behind the curtain of economic disparities should asked. Bottom 50 million of US globalizationwhich suffers from a glut of competing divergent! Reading the papers and watching the news and I really wanted a story in! Look that simple communisteven though he explicitly defends CAPITALISM our collection of motivational and famous Quotes by authors you it. Benefits the bottom 90 percent is to change the structure of the are. Sometimes black people really want to hold onto our oppression - 'This is ours him as a communisteven he... In both cases, the great silver bullet that Thomas Frank debunks his... Theres no more central theme in the first place inequality for all quotes be given the wealth to sustain wealth million US... Is ours wealth than the immorality of inequality the aesthetic opposite of any film by Michael.! Almost shocking now for inequality for all quotes not to do that Smith both men women...