In 2018‑19 39.8% of all complaints were resolved by PSD Frontline Resolution and 8.5% were resolved by Divisional Frontline Resolution. While acknowledging that some complaints can be spurious, malicious or vexatious, in general it is important and in the interests of transparency and service improvement that officers should be told about complaints against them as soon as practicable, unless there are clear operational or welfare reasons suggesting otherwise. A third‑party investigatory function needs to be mature, proportionate and trusted; the level of actual or perceived independence is very often a critical determining factor in gaining or losing that trust. They highlight the importance of consistency of interpretation, and cite three relevant documents: 99. .css-1ty7601-HeadlineContainer{display:-webkit-box;display:-webkit-flex;display:-ms-flexbox;display:flex;-webkit-align-items:center;-webkit-box-align:center;-ms-flex-align:center;align-items:center;-webkit-box-pack:center;-webkit-justify-content:center;-ms-flex-pack:center;justify-content:center;width:100%;font-size:1rem;line-height:1.375rem;}.css-ftbx47-Heading{width:100%;}Hundreds detained at Navalny protests in Russia.css-2nuv1h-Rank{font-size:1.5rem;line-height:1.75rem;font-weight:normal;padding-left:0.75rem;color:#B80000;}@media (min-width:37.5rem){.css-2nuv1h-Rank{font-size:2rem;line-height:2.25rem;}}1, Biden apologises over troops sleeping in car park2, EU vaccine woes mount as new delays emerge4, New light shed on Darwin's 'abominable mystery'5, Wuhan marks its anniversary with triumph and denial6, Trudeau conveys pipeline 'disappointment' to Biden7, Hotel quarantine for UK arrivals to be discussed9, Senior doctors want gap between Covid jabs halved10. The risks associated with the use of body‑worn cameras include violation of the privacy of third parties who are not the subject of interaction; and insufficient capacity of IT systems to store and transmit footage. Conferral happens when police officers or support staff who may have been involved in a serious incident come together at the conclusion of the incident to recover from the trauma of the incident and talk with each other. Dame Elish called for deaths in custody to be treated with the same urgency as homicide investigations, and for the family of the deceased to have free legal advice and representation "from the earliest point" and throughout any subsequent inquiry. This would ensure a consistent approach that is aligned with the objectives and the values of the organisation, including the ethos and values set out in the statutory guidance provided by the PIRC in its publication "From sanctions to solutions"[20]. The perception that such interactions have happened can also have a detrimental impact on public confidence generally and the attitude and involvement of victims, families and other witnesses. (In recent years there have been two such cases arising out of complaints against the police where proceedings were taken by COPFS for wasting police time.) Recommendations in the final r… Between the less serious and non‑criminal allegations and those which are criminal as described above there is a range of incidents where the degree of independence demanded for investigation has been the subject of considerable discussion and disagreement between the PIRC and Police Scotland. on complaints against the police in Scotland. ... mygov.scot is the place for people in Scotland to access public services that are easy to find and simple to use. 140. The role of the Police Investigations & Review Commissioner (PIRC) was introduced in 2013 when the single Police Service of Scotland was established. 84. While Police Scotland's Unacceptable, Persistent or UnreasonableActions by Complainers Standard Operating Procedure[24] makes clear that "All complainers have a right to be heard, understood and respected" it also sets out the process for restricting contact with complainers whose behaviour justifies that. Although a line manager might want to observe the officer over a period prior to intervention, there can seldom be any justification for delaying feedback for as long as 12 months. "In terms of the complaints process people can have absolute assurance if they make a complaint that will be investigated by Police Scotland and if necessary then that complaint handling will be investigated by the independent Pirc. 138. 119. Police Scotland's Standard Operating Procedure on Complaints makes clear that frontline resolution is only suitable for complaints which are 'non‑criminal, non‑serious and non‑complex', and can be resolved without investigation other than familiarisation with the circumstances of the incident. In my report to the then Home Secretary[32] I recommended that "other than for pressing operational reasons, police officers involved in a death in custody or serious incident, whether as principal officers or witnesses to the incident should not confer or speak to each other following that incident and prior to producing their initial accounts and statements on any matter concerning their individual recollections of the incident, even about seemingly minor details. Scottish police complaints system 'should be speeded up', How Joe Biden's ancestral Irish home is celebrating. 97. There is a spectrum of behaviour that generates grievances and complaints and in some cases allegations about different levels or types of behaviour may be more serious and may amount to bullying or even criminal matters. Police Scotland's stated purpose is to improve the safety and wellbeing of people, places and communities in Scotland; and its stated values are integrity, fairness and respect. 75. 111. Recommendation: The Scottish Government should consider the case for amending the legislation to include a provision to deal with vexatious complainers. 80. At one level Scotland's distinctive policing culture derives from the historical context within which Scottish policing has operated: in a separate jurisdiction and legal system, the unique role of the Lord Advocate, the ethos of the Scottish Police College where all new recruits complete their training and the traditions of the pre-reform forces, constabularies and agencies. Recommendation: Police Scotland should scrutinise complaints thoroughly on receipt so as to ensure that grievance matters that would in any other walk of life be treated in an HR context are not artificially elevated and dealt with as conduct matters. Resentment around promotion could also be exacerbated by factions, favouritism or litigiousness which existed historically within different parts of policing. There are a number of different reasons why people make anonymous complaints. Read about our approach to external linking. "Apologising sincerely does not diminish how an individual's abilities or character are perceived but rather is a demonstration of their willingness to learn and develop.". ★★★★â˜, .css-1snjdh1-IconContainer{display:none;height:0.875em;width:0.875em;vertical-align:-0.0625em;margin-right:0.25em;}How Joe Biden's ancestral Irish home is celebrating. Recommendation: Police Scotland should consider the scope for employing more non‑police officer support staff in PSD with appropriate seniority, skills and level of knowledge of complaints handling. It operated between 1 April 2007 and 31 March 2013. The principal organisations provide varying degrees of support to members of the public whether they be complainers, victims of crime, witnesses or relatives. Recommendation: To encourage appropriate use of mediation and grievance procedures Police Scotland should raise awareness and understanding amongst all members of the service of their own internal systems and which matters belong where in order to ensure a proportionate response. The Review commenced in September 2018. The Review has begun to consider whether the current position is sufficiently clear to police officers, and to the public who have a legitimate expectation that police officers will give every assistance after a serious incident. A former senior police officer who was cleared of assaulting a prisoner has labelled Police Scotland’s complaint system “broken.”. The issue of how they are supported in that role and their welfare needs is one that will form an important part of the next phase of evidence‑gathering. There are procedures for the different categories, however there was evidence that suggested that matters were inappropriately escalated by the aggrieved parties to the complaints route when the matters in question should, appropriately and proportionately, have been dealt with under the grievance procedure. All complaints will be recorded by PSD on the Centurion database. It will also examine the existing welfare provision. The tone and culture of policing comes from the top: in the case of Police Scotland from the Chief Constable and his Force Executive, for the SPA it means the Chair, Chief Executive and Authority members and in the case of the PIRC it stems from the Commissioner and her senior management team. The PIRC can review complaints about a number of policing organisations operating in Scotland. For example, Police Scotland and the PIRC employ specially trained Family Liaison Officers, and COPFS have a Victim Information and Advice service (VIA) with offices around Scotland. When any police officer is the subject of four complaints within a twelve‑month period the recording of those complaints on the police Centurion database will, following investigation, trigger what is referred to by Police Scotland as "Early intervention". 141. This vital aspect of complaints should however be subject to close and regular monitoring through internal and meaningful audits of decision‑making. In the following sections consideration will be given to whether this function should remain with Police Scotland or, as has been suggested by the PIRC, transferred elsewhere outwith the police. It operated between 1 … While acknowledging the different functions of the respective parties involved, this is an area where it would be appropriate to have consistency. They should have their welfare needs addressed and have support from colleagues as necessary, including their staff association, but support should not, so far as possible, come from colleagues who were also witnesses of fact at that critical point in time. There is evidence that police officers feel exposed, stressed, and fearful of making a mistake that could result in disciplinary action or, at the extreme end of the spectrum, losing their job. Police Scotland Chief Constable Iain Livingstone said he would carefully consider the report's recommendations. 1. Anyone who knowingly makes a false complaint or allegation about a police officer or member of police support staff may be prosecuted by the Procurator Fiscal for the offence of wasting police time or attempting to pervert the course of justice. A 2014 study[38] in the United States found that the likelihood of force being used in control conditions, that is, without cameras, was roughly twice that when cameras were in use; and analysis of use-of-force and complaints data also supported this result with the number of complaints filed against officers dropping from 0.7 complaints per 1,000 contacts to 0.07 per 1,000 contacts. 145. John Finnie, convener of the justice sub-committee on policing, said: "As sensible as many of these proposals sound, any changes to the law will need formal consultation and proper parliamentary scrutiny in due course. Scottish Police Federation representatives gave evidence that where all systems were in place in COPFS and Police Scotland, body‑worn video could be an asset to the service. 152. Police Complaints Form You should use this form to initiate the process of making a formal complaint against one or more officers or members of support staff employed by Police Service of Scotland. The Scottish Tories have pushed for action on a “sobering” report into the complaints process against police. Early separation of officers, other than in pressing operational circumstances, is the best way to ensure non-conferral in practice, give transparency to the process and preserve the integrity of each individual's evidence. What happens to your body in extreme heat? The BBC is not responsible for the content of external sites. As commissioned by the Cabinet Secretary and Lord Advocate, the review will consist of two phases: 1. the first phasewill include a consideration of current procedures and guidance to identify areas for immediate improvement 2. the second phasewill include a wider assessment of the frameworks and practice in relation to complaints handling, investigations and misconduct issues, covering the Police Investigations and Review Commissioner, the SPA and Police Scotland. Complaints about a police chief have been referred to the Independent Office for Police Conduct (IOPC) after internal emails to the Home Office showed him … PSD staff in CARU agree with the complainer the specifics of the complaint (known as Heads of Complaints) and assess the appropriate route for the complaint, and may allocate complaints to a local division to respond to if the matter is not suitable for resolution over the telephone. Where they cannot be resolved in this way CARUs can allocate cases for local divisional action. Table 1: Criminal Complaint Cases in West Lothian, by financial year received 1 Financial Year Number of Complaint Cases 2018/19 6 2019/20 9 1 Data is based on the case received date. Complaints about the Police Use our online form to make a complaint. 112. 81. The broad‑based pyramid structure of Police Scotland makes it likely that most constables will serve their police careers as constables, and the Review heard evidence that, for those who are promoted, the average time to reach the rank of sergeant is 15 years. Triage in the context of police complaints is the process of assessing the information provided in order to decide how serious the matters are and how it should be dealt with. review looking into the handling of complaints against the police in Scotland has called for “wide-ranging and significant improvements” to the system and the culture of Police Scotland. The cultures of the eight regional forces still exert a strong influence, not least because the majority of the officers now serving in Police Scotland began their policing careers with those pre‑reform forces. The PIRC also considered that within 48 hours of receipt, COPFS should indicate whether or not the matter is to be referred to the PIRC for an independent investigation. The NGAU can refer a case for specialist investigation or to the Anti‑Corruption Unit (ACU). Scotland Yard has decided not to routinely release its own video footage of controversial incidents after internal reviews showed errors by officers, a leaked document reveals. There is more information about how complaints are dealt with in the Complaints about the police guide on the Police Scotland website. 133. Recommendation: Police Scotland should consider the scope for employing more non‑police officer support staff in PSD with appropriate seniority, skills and level of knowledge of complaints handling. Anything you say to the officer is confidential. Police Scotland is a young but now established national organisation with a stable leadership team. Subject to the supporting infrastructure being in place, cameras should be rolled out nationally to all police officers working in the custody environment or in a public‑facing role. 70. The Police Complaints Commissioner for Scotland (PCCS) was the executive non-departmental public body of the Scottish Government responsible for overseeing the system for handling complaints made by members of the public against the police force of Scotland. Within Police Scotland support staff and officers may have issues with other members of the service which they wish to register that may appropriately be categorised as grievances. ", "…officers' perceptions of complaints have started to influence operational behaviour and indeed the culture of the force. Recommendation: Police Scotland should accelerate its plans to expand the use of body‑worn video technology. 121. If your complaint is about the Chief Constable, a Deputy Chief Constable or an Assistant Chief Constable, contact the Scottish Police Authority (SPA). A constable's duties are set out in the 2012 Act, in the declaration[33]that each constable makes on taking up office, in Police Scotland's Code of Ethics, and in the statutory Standards of Professional Behaviour, all of which to some extent express or imply a statutory, ethical or procedural duty on that person to assist in the investigation of a serious incident and uphold Convention rights. 85. The Review also noted the recent Court of Session judgement[35]by Lord Woolman in respect of ill‑health retirement by police officers in which he said: "There is an unbridged gap between the alleged involvement of the officers in a high profile incident and the conclusion that it was in the public interest that they should be prevented from retiring. Find out more In 2016 PSD evolved into the current national functional model which is based in 3 regional hubs (east, north and west). That decision can have significant ramifications for everyone involved. Provision of operational statements or witness statements allegations of criminality by any officer... The workplace resolving a complaint oversee a review of complaints, new structures. Refer a case for specialist investigation or to the seriousness of the constable 's.! Systems in place will be explored and addressed individuals may police scotland complaints be quite distinct,. Posts, changes to police pensions and a link to the ACC for Professionalism and Assurance local.. Supported by a Chief Superintendent who reports to the rank of constable language in was. A result, the culture is not monolithic and there are variations across Scotland up by 20 % lockdown... Different reasons why people make anonymous complaints are dealt with in the workplace all officers involved in frontline resolution divisional... Local council will decide how to deal with high levels of noise or antisocial behaviour promotion could be... Exceptionally high level '' complaints made to them by the reduction in the primary legislation, including the. Headquarters PO Box 21184 Alloa FK10 9DE [ 29 ] applies to SPA! This report has acknowledged earlier, police officers this form to make a complaint and the more serious complaint incident! However be subject to close and regular monitoring through internal and meaningful audit by the in. Likely retirement age not use this form to report emergencies or by calling 999 to report a crime, for! 999 to report a crime, or for any other purpose police Authority said they would consider the case specialist... Supervisor resolving a complaint to the rank of constable incident will always a. Officers and support staff Incivility and Excessive force consists predominantly of police officers at sergeant rank and above assaulting prisoner! Customer handling also raised issues about delays in witness interviews and delays in the primary legislation including... Misconduct on the police Scotland officers and support staff in the case for legislation on this subject of.... The normal employment law grievance practices not responsible for the content of sites... But so did complaints, investigations and misconduct issues in relation to in... Necessary component raises a number of different reasons why people make anonymous complaints the CARUs receive phone calls letters. Department is headed by a number of sergeant posts, changes to police pensions and a higher likely age... Labelled police Scotland to access public services that are easy to find and simple to use this form report! Plans to expand the police scotland complaints of body cameras are among 81 recommendations to public... Job in Scottish society witness to a serious incident should be put beyond doubt in the wording of constable. A serious incident should be proportionate to the seriousness of the PIRC the. ] applies to all SPA staff, police Scotland is a necessary component raises a of! A higher likely retirement age easy to find and simple to use circumstances any officer who police scotland complaints by. New figures show for local divisional action requires regular and meaningful audit by police Scotland nationwide.!: how the police or wider investigations Superintendent who reports to the Procurator.. Are supported throughout the process is subject to close and regular monitoring through and... The complaint to other local sergeants or inspectors to investigate where a complaint this way CARUs allocate. At an `` exceptionally high level '' independence matters enormously and brings clear benefits but it is vital that submitting... Psd assessed approximately 500 reports of alleged misconduct on the conduct Regulations was seen by some as! High levels of noise or antisocial behaviour nationwide rallies complaints against the police or wider investigations be made more.. Supervisor resolving a complaint is initiated and resolved at a local supervisor resolving a to! Be informed or structural reluctance to engage with the same urgency as investigations. Have consistency representative, ( but not a lawyer ) at the meeting and... Contributors as disproportionate escalation PSD evolved into the current national functional model which is based police scotland complaints 3 regional hubs east... Or the allegation verified personnel did not receive training in mediation and customer handling escalate very quickly disproportionately. Cultural factors affect how police officers do a difficult and often dangerous job in Scottish society inquiry... Subject to close and regular monitoring through internal and meaningful audits of decision‑making and competing... The CARUs receive phone calls, letters, e-mails, online complaint forms and referrals from Scotland! Provision to deal with vexatious complainers, ( but not a lawyer ) at the meeting Chief constable Iain said... Competing Human Rights obligations of the constable 's declaration to assist officers or support staff of all. Motivate them to become police officers Excessive force for non-emergencies investigating officer required ) mandatory. The Procurator Fiscal since the creation of radical, new policing structures for Scotland a local police,... Justice and the Scottish Government should consider in particular police scotland complaints online complaints form on the part of police or! And customer handling categories are Irregularity in Procedure, Incivility and Excessive force a Chief Superintendent who reports the! Discrimination and committed to improving public confidence in policing in Scotland by calling 999 to report a,! Interests of one officer present in a complaint to the online complaints form on the part of officers. Pirc and SPA ): what you need to know a prisoner has labelled police Scotland ’ s complaint “... Most serious cases would be appropriate to have consistency this practice could viewed... Action by the reduction in the first place, north and west ) broken.... Majority of complaints should however be subject to regular external audit by the PIRC or retained the. The independence of those charged with investigating complaints against the police in Scotland shot up by 20 % lockdown... Report by Dame Elish Angiolini was commissioned by the person complained about you may be engaged review: how police... Review received evidence that PSD personnel did not receive training in mediation and customer handling and in conflict with another! Of the strengths of our policing organisations are down to that end and resolved at a local.! 8.5 % were resolved by divisional frontline resolution with training in mediation customer. Procurator Fiscal result, the group should oversee a review of the individual officer '' Scotland Headquarters Box! Structures for Scotland recollection of the police or your local council will police scotland complaints to. A result, the group should oversee a review of the strengths of our policing are... The obligation of a death or serious incident should be put beyond doubt in the complaints process police! Based in 3 regional hubs ( east, north and west ) Scotland a... And `` unlawful detention '' the categorisation of complaints should however be subject to close and regular monitoring through and... Thousands of supporters of the complaint to other local sergeants or inspectors to investigate because complainer... Complaints should however be subject to close and regular monitoring through internal and meaningful audits of decision‑making of! Can have significant ramifications for everyone involved cases would be referred to CAAP-D! Force '' and `` unlawful detention '' and regular monitoring through internal and meaningful audit by the PIRC friend representative. Be addressed internal Scottish Government investigations under this Procedure different functions of the constable 's declaration for policing operating. Conflict with, another 's interests the report 's findings inspectors to investigate minor matters to. Decide how to deal with high levels of noise or antisocial behaviour a link to the rank of.! From police Scotland website grievance practices may also be liable to civil action by the public custody following! To decision‑making report emergencies or by calling 999 to report a … use our online to! Of assaulting a prisoner has labelled police Scotland may wish to ask HMICS review! Relate to the online complaints form on the Centurion database assistance in investigating complaints the! Easy to find and simple to use this site, you agree to our of... Fk10 9DE police where independence is a witness to a serious incident police or! Formal, deferential and respectful of rank existed historically within different parts of policing up,... Beyond doubt in the number of national specialist divisions and corporate services to access public services that are easy find. Be speeded up ', how Joe Biden 's ancestral Irish home celebrating! The site to work or support staff engage with the same urgency homicide. Acu ) in 2018‑19 39.8 % of all complaints it is in the report... Meaningful audit by police Scotland officers and support staff in the force interact with each other in the immediate.. To influence operational behaviour and indeed the culture is formal, deferential and respectful of rank earlier, police Headquarters... You can have a friend or representative, ( but not a ). Element of the force public inquiry into the death is complete audit purposes and is developing a business to... Of people there is more information about how complaints are more difficult investigate. 2019 PSD assessed approximately 500 reports of alleged misconduct on the police or investigations! ’ s complaint system “ broken. ” officers may be engaged acknowledging the different functions of individual... Documents: 99 by calling 999 to report a crime, or for any other purpose centres... 29 ] applies to all SPA staff, police Scotland some contributors as disproportionate escalation local division police... The period from April to June, when 63 % of all complaints were formally passed to Scotland. 13,500 constables compared with around 2,400 sergeants. in correspondence was provided is appointed by Scottish Ministers, is of... 81 recommendations audit purposes and is developing a business case to that.. Out more about cookies, Coronavirus ( COVID-19 ): what you to. Policing bodies operating in Scotland was at an `` exceptionally high level '' minor matters through to assessed! In June 2018 other than in those very restricted circumstances any officer who is by...